rmp-logormp-logormp-logormp-logo
  • Why RMP
  • Who we work with
  • Resources
  • Insights
  • People
  • Get in touch
  • Risk Portal
Published by Risk Management Partners on October 30, 2019
Categories
  • Casualty
  • Claims
  • Environment
  • Fire
  • Government
  • Local government
  • Motor
  • NHS
  • Police
  • Resources
  • Transport
Tags
  • Motor

Motor Vehicle Insurance - Use by volunteers of their own vehicles

Home > Motor Vehicle Insurance – Use by volunteers of their own vehicles

Overview

The following paper is designed to bring the subject matter to the attention of interested parties, and in no way does it offer, or attempt to offer, a definitive legal view, interpretation of the law, or comment on the views and position of other insurers. Readers should always seek their own advice and guidance from suitably qualified legal and insurance organisations.

A not untypical enquiry we deal with on a regular basis is what insurance is there within the parameters of the authority’s insurance programme for volunteers who are using their own vehicle, arguably for the benefit of the authority. For these purposes a volunteer might be a parent taking a sports team to a match or a social services volunteer delivering meals.

There is a fundamental principle within motor insurance that the insurance cover should ideally follow the registered owner of the vehicle. In this context then in the first instance the parents, or the social services volunteer, should contact their own motor insurers and enquire whether such insurers are happy to treat the usage of the vehicle in this way as an extension to the Social and Domestic Pleasure coverage. Assuming the volunteer does not get paid for the activity and it is purely voluntarily, then most reasonable insurers should take a realistic position and confirm that the policy will operate to offer an indemnity.

It should be recognised though that if such a matter was to come before the courts then it may well be the courts who decide with insurers and the police purely taking a view on the matter, as to whether a usage is Business or Social Domestic and Pleasure usage.

The following two legal precedents are useful when considering such scenarios:

‘…If the policyholder … gave a lift as a matter of kindness, courtesy or charity … the proper view would be that the car was being used for a social purpose.’

Passmore v Vulcan Boiler and General Insurance Co Ltd (1935)]

However, a more modern day approach is for the court to look for the primary purpose, or essential character, of the journey when deciding the use of the vehicle. They ‘should not be meticulous to find some possible secondary purpose … the result of which could be suggested to be that the use … fell outside the proper use…’
[Seddon v Binions (1977)]

In this case they go on to say where there is a definite case of the vehicle being used for two ‘purposes’ then the decision in Passmore would still be valid.

In our example of the parent, the question that needs considering is whether the offer of taking children constitutes an act of kindness, courtesy or charity or would the primary purpose of the vehicle being used be that of the authority? A considered view maybe that the use would be construed as social, especially if the parent is purely transporting their own child. However, if a formal arrangement exists between the school and the parent(s) to transport other children (as opposed to arrangements between the parents themselves) then it possibly edges more towards business use. Any payment to the parent, however small, may strengthen this argument.

Where an insurer refuses to offer the coverage they may well suggest that such usage is actually the usage of the authority (which arguably it is), and that the only way they can extend the policy is by way of endorsement for an additional premium, or refuse altogether and place the onus for the cover back with the authority. Some volunteers may indeed view this as the most desirable route, especially if a charge is likely to be made. Volunteers should be advised that should they continue to drive as a ‘volunteer’ in circumstances, where their insurer has refused to extend the motor policy, then they could be potentially driving uninsured.

One solution available to authorities is to arrange a separate occasional business use (OBU) extension to their fleet policy and to allow this extension to be used by the parents/volunteers, when transporting children to and from organised activities.

This would give the volunteer the appropriate motor insurance cover required. The OBU coverage would offer no greater cover to the volunteer than they enjoy under their own motor policy coverage.

OBU coverage should not be confused with Motor Contingent Liability (MCL), which is a feature of most public liability and motor insurance covers. An MCL extension only provides coverage to the authority (not the driver), for third party risks when a non-authority owned vehicle is being driven on the business of the insured and is not insured for such usage.

How can we help you?

For more advice on how we can help lower the cost of your risk, please email contact@rmpartners.co.uk

Unsubscribe

You can opt out of marketing communications at any time by contacting us.

Download Resource

Download the Motor Vehicle Insurance - Use by volunteers of their own vehicles PDF

Related Resources

Tree root claims...

Dogs in Schools...

Skateparks – A Guide for Local Authorities...

Judicial College Guidelines Update – March 2024...

Street Lighting Advice for Local Authorities...

Risk Assessment – Suitable and Sufficient?...

Office Chairs and Fire Safety...

Lighting for Car Parks...

Aggregate stop loss protection...

Cycling to and at work...

Personal Protective Equipment (PPE)...

Autonomous Vehicles: Ethical Decisions and the Impact o...

The RAPP Tool...

Free Running...

Laser Safety in Higher Education...

Bodycams in Higher Education – Better Safety...

Solar Panel Installations...

Safety in Managing Street Works – Chapter 8...

Taking Pride in Zebra Crossings...

The American XL Bully...

Market (Injury) Claims Update & Impact of the Whip...

Artificial Intelligence in Higher Education...

Dangers from Cobalt in Lithium-ion Battery Fires...

Martyn’s Law – The Protect Duty – A C...

Bike Pool Schemes...

Police Vehicles – Use of Bait and Entrapment Vehicles...

Volunteers – Risk Management Guidance...

Industry Highlights – October 2023...

Managing Choking Risk...

Managing Manual Handling...

Manual Handling: MAC Tool...

Martyn’s Law – The Protect Duty – A C...

Driving and the Menopause...

Risk Management for Public Events...

Bullying, Harassment and Discrimination...

EV Safety Guidance...

What does the energy crisis mean for public spaces?...

General Safety Regulations 2024...

Managing Agency Drivers...

Section 114 Notices...

Managing Roofs in Higher Education...

ESG – Higher Education...

E-Cargo Bikes...

Business continuity management...

Whistleblowing and Safeguarding – Higher Educatio...

BT Redcare Closure...

ESG...

Staying ready – an insight into health and safety regul...

Bite Size Virtual Training Programme – Casualty Risk Q3...

Bonfires & Fireworks Displays – Higher Education...

Bite Size Virtual Training Programme – Fleet Risk Manag...

Whistleblowing and Safeguarding...

Managing the Highways...

RMP Risk Control – Public Sector State of the Nation Re...

Student Suicide Awareness and Management...

Slips, Trips & Falls Toolkit – Winter Weathe...

Protecting Buildings from Vehicle Attacks...

Asbestos Management in Higher Education...

Managing the Risks from Diabetes...

Assurance Reporting in Higher Education...

Claims Cost Inflation...

The Rise of Artificial Intelligence...

RMP Risk Control – Formula Student...

Managing Risks associated with Swimming Pools in Educat...

Slips, Trips & Falls Toolkit – Risk Insight...

Unoccupied Premises...

Managing Sleep Debt...

Work Experience Placements...

RMP Risk Control – Permit-to-work management...

Seat Belt Buckle Guards...

Wheel Security...

RMP Risk Control – Thermal comfort at work...

Research Projects which need to be referred to RMP / HD...

RMP Risk Control – Supervised and Unsupervised Gyms...

Slips, Trips & Falls Toolkit – Contamination...

Managing risks associated with online vehicle booking s...

Slips, Trips & Falls Toolkit – Incident Inve...

Slips, Trips & Falls Toolkit – Human Factors...

Managing Graduations...

Slips, Trips & Falls Toolkit – Slip Resistan...

Joint Venture Risks...

Mould in Landlord Controlled Properties...

RMP Risk Control – Preventing Falls from Windows...

Slips, Trips & Falls Toolkit – Cleaning Regi...

Broker Bulletin No. 19 – Police vehicles – drivin...

Bite Size Virtual Training Programme – Fleet and Driver...

Bite Size Virtual Training Programme – Casualty Risk...

Slips, Trips & Falls Toolkit – Flooring, Cle...

Slips, Trips & Falls Toolkit – Entrances...

New and Expectant Mothers at Work and Study...

Summer Driving...

Assistance Dogs, Service Dogs and Puppy Therapy...

Working at Height Toolkit – Fall Restraint...

Employees Domiciled Abroad – Higher Education...

Bite Size Virtual Training Programme – Casualty R...

Risk Management Health Check...

Slips, Trips & Falls Toolkit – Stairs &...

Slips, Trips & Falls Toolkit – Managing Trip...

Employees Domiciled Abroad...

Whiplash Reforms Update – August 2023...

Personal Data Breaches in Higher Education...

Slips, Trips & Falls Toolkit – Footwear...

Lanyards While Driving...

Working at Height Toolkit – Fall Arrest...

IICSA: The End of Limitation?...

Community Speed Watch...

Working at Height Toolkit – Scaffolding...

Bite Size Virtual Training Programme – Fleet ...

Introduction to Essentials for Enterprise Risk Manageme...

Essentials for Enterprise Risk Management (EERM) in Hig...

Working at Height Toolkit – Introduction...

Personal Data Breaches in Public Sector...

Working at Height Toolkit – Fall Protection...

Working at Height Toolkit – Fragile Roofs and Sur...

Managing Woodland Visitors...

Martyn’s Law – The Protect Duty Legislation...

E-Bikes and E-Scooters – The Perils of Lithium-io...

IICSA: The Proposal of a National Redress Scheme for En...

Key Control: how good is your key security?...

Managing Risks Associated with Refuse Vehicles...

Ergonomics and Display Screen Equipment Use...

Ash Dieback...

IICSA: An Analysis of Recommendation 6 of the Final Rep...

The Ups and Downs of Trampoline Parks...

Vaping and the Workplace...

Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse Final Repor...

An Analysis of the Mandatory Reporting Requirement prop...

Forest School...

20’s Plenty...

Refuse Collections...

County Lines Drug Running...

Broker Bulletin No. 1 – Defibrillators...

Parkruns...

Well Managed Highways Infrastructure Code of Practice...

Safe Systems of Work – Safe Use of Ladders and St...

E-Scooters...

Competency of Structures Inspectors...

Ice on the Road...

Blue Light Trauma Awareness and Management...

Managing Grass Cutting: A Case Study...

Cycling Events...

Risk Information & Intelligence...

Risks in Outsourcing...

Broker Bulletin No. 17 – Looked After Children an...

Contract Works Cover and Cover for Existing Structures ...

Broker Bulletin No. 18 – Contract Works and Conti...

Fraud...

Highway Code Changes...

Highways Competency Framework...

Firework Risk Management Questionnaire...

Stress Management for Homeworkers...

Managing Inland Open Water (including Ice)...

Bonfires and Fireworks Displays...

Cyber Attacks...

W-8BEN-E – FATCA AIG Europe Limited...

Social Engineering and Deepfakes...

RMP Tenders – Information Required for Quotations...

Contractors Training & Discussion Workshop...

Play – The Universal Language of Children...

Towing Legislation...

Stress Risk Management for Emergency Services...

Fireworks – Planning a safe display...

Not My Responsibility...

Automated and Electric Vehicles...

E-Scooters on Higher Education Campuses...

Construction Design and Management (CDM) – The Es...

Employment Relations (Flexible Working) Act 2023...

Managing Risks associated with Grey Fleet Vehicles...

Drones and Model Aeroplanes...

Electronic Signatures...

Managing Drivers with Diabetes...

Display Screen Equipment...

Social Engineering...

Children and Young People within a Higher Education Wor...

Electrical Safety...

Home Food Preparation for Schools...

Misfuelling a Vehicle...

Safe Storage and Use of Vapes...

Inflatable Structures...

Managing Risks associated with Hand Arm Vibration Syndr...

Claims Handlers (Auditing)...

W-8BEN-E – FATCA Ecclesiastical Insurance Office ...

Keyless Vehicle Entry Systems – Relay Theft...

Students – Sports Injuries...

Managing Protests in Higher Education...

Broker Bulletin No. 3 – Insurance Act 2015...

Virtual Tree Masterclass – Save The Date...

Combating Bed Bugs...

W-8BEN-E – FATCA MS Amlin AG...

Combating Bed Bugs – Higher Education...

Operator Licence Changes...

W-8BEN-E – Underwriters at Lloyd’s London...

Stress Risk Management – Higher Education...

W-8IMY – FATCA Risk Management Partners Limited...

Managing First Aid...

Homeworking...

Waste Collection and Culture – Risk Management Gu...

Stress Risk Management...

Safe Storage and Use of Vapes – Higher Education...

The viability of care homes...

Managing First Aid – Higher Education...

Allergies & Risk of Anaphylaxis in Schools...

Children and young people within a Blue Light workplace...

Combined Liability – Decision Tree and Treatment ...

W-8BEN-E – FATCA Mitsui Sumitomo Insurance Compan...

Proper Footwear...

Broker Bulletin No. 2 – Local Pension Boards ...

W-8BEN-E – FATCA HSB Engineering Insurance Limite...

Refuse Collection Operations Risk Management – Safety C...

Preventing slips on snow and ice...

Broker Bulletin No. 13 – Regional Adoption Agenci...

Broker Bulletin No. 5 – Employees Own Vehicles &#...

Storage of Hazardous Substances in Educational Establis...

Tree Safety – Managing the Risks...

W-8BEN-E – FATCA Starr International (Europe) Lim...

Dementia Awareness for Managers of Drivers...

Broker Bulletin No. 4 – Contract Works Cover ...

Controlling the casualty risks associated with unmanned...

W-8BEN-E – FATCA QBE Insurance (Europe) Limited...

Children’s Trusts...

How an underwriter sets a premium...

Shared Services – where are we now...

Social Media & Social Responsibility – Highe...

Contract Works Insurance...

Time for a Check Up...

Broker Bulletin No. 8 – Police Risks – Dete...

Broker Bulletin No. 11 – New PL & EL Policy ...

Preventing & Controlling Unauthorised Access to Ro...

Small events risk management...

Broker Bulletin No. 7 – POLICE Risks – Memo...

Broker Bulletin No. 9 – Police Risks – Nati...

Authority Business – Using Your Own Vehicle...

How to complete your renewal questionnaire...

Social Media & Social Responsibility...

Legionella – Risk Controls...

Sign up to receive the latest from rmp

    You can opt out of marketing communications at any time by contacting us

    Sign up to receive the latest from RMP

    For information on how we use your personal data please refer to our UK Privacy Notice | EEA Privacy Notice.

      You can opt out of marketing communications at any time by contacting us

      RMP

      • Classes of insurance
      • Resources
      • Why RMP
      • Insights
      • Get in touch

      Sectors

      • Local government
      • Police
      • Fire services
      • Education institutions

      Legal

      • Complaints
      • Cookie policy
      • Global privacy policy
      • Lloyd’s Brexit Transfer
      • Modern Slavery Agreement
      • Terms and conditions

      Follow Us

      • LinkedIn
      • Twitter

      © Risk Management Partners Ltd All rights reserved. Authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority number 313119. Registered in England number 2989025. The Walbrook Building, 25 Walbrook, London, EC4N 8AW